Adobe Stock
Adobe Stock
In 2021, 17 farmers in cities within Manistee County received a total of $232,311 in 32 farm subsidies, a 49.5% decrease compared to 2020, when the total was $460,333 in 53 farm subsidies.
Though farm subsidies support agriculture in the U.S., pumping $7 trillion into the economy, they are not without controversy.
The American Action Forum discovered that the most highly subsidized crops - corn, soy, wheat, and rice - are often consumed in highly processed ways, which leads to unhealthy eating habits and obesity, while the fruits and vegetables needed for a healthy diet are rarely subsidized.
"We are consuming more calories, fats, sodium, and sugars, and not enough beneficial nutrients and vitamins," Tara O'Neill Hayes wrote. "It is critical that both policymakers and the American public understand the influence that federal agricultural subsidies have on our food supply and diet and, in turn, our nutrition and health."
Farm subsidies have also been criticized for assisting the highest-earning agricultural businesses, not local farmers on their family farms who are barely getting by.
Kimberly Amadeo of The Balance said farmer subsidies "help high-income corporations, not poor rural farmers. Most of the money goes toward large agribusinesses."
The U.S. has provided farm subsidies since the Great Depression to assist farmers who weather price fluctuations and disasters, to help maintain consistent farming across the country.
| Farmer | Total Received in 2020 | Total Received in 2021 | % Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calvin Lutz II | $150,769 | $66,609 | -55.8% |
| Gregory Gilroy | $78,180 | $55,354 | -29.2% |
| Robert Gentz Forest Products, Inc. | $0 | $52,875 | -- |
| Ronald Gillison | $69,006 | $26,375 | -61.8% |
| Alvin Stoll | $21,335 | $14,981 | -29.8% |
| Darryl Howes Farms | $7,917 | $4,167 | -47.4% |
| Monroe Forest Products | $0 | $3,476 | -- |
| Allen Grossnickle | $34,883 | $3,079 | -91.2% |
| Samsal Farm, LLP | $5,254 | $1,852 | -64.8% |
| Guy John Garrett | $2,456 | $987 | -59.8% |
| Carl Milarch | $1,730 | $744 | -57% |
| David W. Beck | $0 | $670 | -- |
| Browns Poplar Ridge Orchards, LLC | $0 | $500 | -- |
| Bruce Bahr | $279 | $279 | 0% |
| Scott Aitken | $0 | $231 | -- |
| John Amrhein | $728 | $114 | -84.3% |
| Edward G. Buysse | $0 | $18 | -- |
| Allen a Hulkonen | $3,715 | $0 | -100% |
| Calvin Clare Lutz III | $4,121 | $0 | -100% |
| Jared Lutz Farms, LLC | $2,728 | $0 | -100% |
| Joel Meister | $145 | $0 | -100% |
| Apple Valley Orchards of Manistee, LLC | $28,969 | $0 | -100% |
| Browns Poplar Ridge Orchards | $48,118 | $0 | -100% |
| Total subsidies | $460,333 | $232,311 | -49.5% |
Alerts Sign-up